Phonological similarity effects are explained by the phonological loop. Pdf the phonological similarity effect in immediate. Phonological similarity in working memory span tasks. This finding has often been cited as evidence for the use of phonological coding in shortterm memory and working memory. However, some studies have demonstrated a reversal of the phonological similarity effect under certain conditions. Loss and decay are most consequential when an item is phonologically similar to another item already in the phonological store. This study shows that the classical phonological similarity effect pse in immediate serial recall is critically affected by the lexicality of list items, the type of phonological similarity involved, and the scoring procedure. Pdf the phonological similarity effect in immediate recall. Phonological similarity effects in simple and complex word spans. The phonological similarity effect on memory span in children. Phonological similarity effect article about phonological.
But most young kids are getting ready to read long before they. Phonological similarity, pronunciation rate, and memory span. Coglab phonological similarity brandon cole phonological. In our first two experiments, we show that the effect actually reverses following relatively brief periods of distraction, yielding better order retention for similar than for dissimilar.
Although many variables are known to affect vwm, we focus primarily on the effects of two factors. Working memory is a cognitive system with a limited capacity that can hold information temporarily. The phonological similarity effect in shortterm memory serial. Reversing the phonological similarity effect semantic. Phonemic similarity effects and prelexical phonology. This phonological similarity effect pse is known to affect their maintenance of verbal information. Experiments 14 compared background speech that shared virtually no phonemes with the visual stimuli with background speech that shared all of the phonemes of the visual stimuli.
Pdf reversing the phonological similarity effect researchgate. Phonological similarity effect in childrens working. Phonological similarity affected the learning of novel words more than known words experiment 1. The detrimental effect of the word phonological similarity. The relative contributions of intralist and interlist interference were compared, and differential effects on item and order memory were observed. The phonological similarity effect poor retention of order for lists of similarsounding itemsis a benchmark finding in the shortterm memory literature. The phonological similarity effect in shortterm memory serial recall in schizophrenia. Pdf that phonologically similar words in a shortterm memory test are more difficult to recall than.
By using the same set of memoranda, but differing the secondarytask requirements across experiments, we showed that a phonological similarity facilitation effect is dependent upon the semantic relationship between the memoranda and. Reversing the phonological similarity effect semantic scholar. To determine how phonological similarity affects brain function during vwm, standard and similarity versions of the 2back task were presented to 34 healthy participants during functional magnetic resonance imaging fmri. Opposing effects of phonological similarity on item and order. By using the same set of memoranda, but differing the secondarytask requirements across experiments, we showed that a phonological similarity facilitation effect is dependent upon the semantic relationship between the.
When people are asked to recall a list of items, their performance is usually worse when the items sound similar than when the items sound different conrad, 1964. The explanation of the results, however, becomes more complex when one takes into consideration the reason why the production of continuous speech did not affect the phonological similarity effect. Psychology and mental health chinese language psychological aspects computational linguistics grammar, comparative and general phonology research interpersonal relations language processing linguistic research natural language interfaces natural language. The roles of type of similarity, category cueing, and item recall a classic. Phonological similarity effects in verbal complex span. Experiment 5 replicatedthe method of salame and baddeleys critical experiment but not their results. When people are asked to recall a list of items, their.
Despite this study supporting the hypothesis that there is a phonological effect that influences the ability to successfully recall more letters that are dissimilar in nature as opposed to those that share common phonological similarities, the use of the phonological loop in retaining sequences of familiar letterswords is, it is argued. Its the ability to recognize and work with sounds in spoken language. Vitevitch, who is now at the spoken language laboratory, department of psychology, 1415 jayhawk boulevard, university of kansas, lawrence, kansas 66045. Pdf phonological similarity effect in complex span task. A phonological similarity effect pse in adolescents with an intellectual disability id has previously been shown with auditory stimuli, but studies using visual stimuli are scarce. Reexamining the phonological similarity effect in immediate serial recall. The phonological store construct of the working memory model is critically evaluated. Three experiments demonstrated consistent effects of phonological similarity on listening span.
Article information, pdf download for the phonologicalsimilarity effect. However, unlike previous research the phonological similarity effect was not. Constraints on theories of memory the phonological similarity effect in shortterm serial recall refers to the wellreplicated finding that lists composed of similarsounding items are less accurately recalled in the correct. The influence of phonological similarity neighborhoods on. Pdf the phonological similarity effectpoor retention of order for lists of similar sounding itemsis a benchmark finding in the shortterm. Also word length disrupted the learning of novel words, but not of known words experiment 3. Volume 112, issue 1, 15 september 2002, pages 7781.
Reversing the phonological similarity effect pdf paperity. Three experiments test the prediction that the effect of irrelevant sound and the effect of phonological similarity each survive the action of articulatory suppression but only when presentation of. The phonologicalsimilarity effect supports the phonological loop models assumption that verbal information is represented in a modalityspecific phonological store rather than in another type of storage system such as a visual or semantic buffer. What is the role of tone in phonologicalsimilarity effect. Although there was a tendency for similarity within the irrelevant items to reduce interference. The phonological loop model for retention of auditory verbal material in working memory, developed by baddeley, assumes that irrelevant speech and phonological similarity influence only one and the same element of the systemthat is, the phonological shortterm store.
Although this effect has become known as the phonological similarity effect, a better term is the acoustic similarity effect because what matters is that the items sound similar to each other. Post hoc comparisons supported our proposed explanation by revealing that the low acceptance of vowel quantity contrasts largely reflects phonological similarity. Vitevitch correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to michael s. On the other hand, if phonological similarity has an effect via trace competition, it will decrease the probability of redintegration ofa degraded representation. Phonological similarity effect in childrens working memory. Pdf reexamining the phonological similarity effect in. The theory proposed a model containing three components. The majority of investigations on phonological similarity effects have required participants to simply store and maintain items in memorya type of task often referred to as simple span. Studies of verbal working memory vwm report that performance declines as the phonemic similarity of stimuli increases.
Pse was present in the serial recall score when phonologically distinct words were compared to words that share the middle vowel and end consonant rhyming lists. It has been researched that serial recall is 25% worse if a list of words was phonologically. This effect is the phonological similarity decrement. This suggests that the brain recodes information in the way it sounds. The phonological loop model for retention of auditory verbal material in working memory, developed by baddeley, assumes that irrelevant speech and phonological similarity influence only one and. Phonological shortterm memory and the learning of novel. Earlier literature proposes two ways phonological similarity could harm immediate recall. More recent work has extended the investigation of the phonological similarity effect from simple to complex span. Phonological similarity effects in simple and complex word. Study of the phonological similarity effect pse in immediate serial recall isr. The weak modifications of wordlength effect and phonological similarity effect seem to confirm that these effects are not due to the rehearsal strategy use. What is the role of tone in the phonological similarity effect. Phonological similarity effect reexamined 3 reexamining the phonological similarity effect in immediate serial recall.
Some kids pick it up naturally, but others need more help with it. Phonological shortterm memory and the learning of novel words. The quarterly journal of experimental psychology section a. By using the same set of memoranda, but differing the secondarytask requirements across experiments, we showed that a phonological similarity facilitation effect is dependent upon the semantic relationship between the memoranda and the secondarytask stimuli, and is robust to changes in the representation, ordering, and pool size of the secondarytask stimuli. Kelley purdue university, west lafayette, indiana the phonological similarity effect poor retention of order for lists of similarsounding itemsis a benchmark finding in the shortterm memory literature. Our primetarget items were designed to test predictions derived from cohort theorys emphasis on the primacy of lefttoright processing in auditory word recognition. People often think that reading begins with learning to sound out letters. Applying this logic to the serbocroatianresults, phonological coding must be mandatory and routine in ordinary word. The phonological similarity effect in working memory. A phonologicalsimilarity effect was observed only in the task that involved sequential. A considerable amount of cognitive, behavioural research has been conducted on the working memory model and the role of the phonological loop and similarity effects on the serial recall paradigm. In our first two experiments, we show that the effect actually reverses following relatively brief periods of distraction, yielding better order retention for. If phonological similarity is included as a predictor, the effect of.
The phonologicalsimilarity effect differentiates between two. Because similarity in prosodic information, unlike the similarity in segmental information, will not create any interference effect in working memory, but a facilitatory effect will occur in working memory instead, which means the interference pse is less effective to tonerhymed. Opposing effects of phonological similarity on item and. What is most surprising about the phonological similarity effect is that it occurs even when there is no auditory input, such as when you read the items silently to yourself. Working memory is often used synonymously with shortterm memory, but some theorists consider the two forms of memory distinct, assuming that working memory allows for the manipulation of stored.
Phonological similarity and the irrelevant speech effect. The effect of phonological similarity and item length. Original article, report by the psychological record. This is because there is no possibility for the read information to be recoded the way it sounds. Phonological awareness is the foundation for learning to read. In the present study, we were interested in the effect of wordinitial phonological similarity on lexical decision times. Concerning the classic pse, the present study brought further evidence on its existence in children. The phonological priming effects observed in their study may be due, in part, to overall syllabic similarity and the fact that the entire target item nap appeared intact in the prime napkin. This theoretical framework predicts that phonologically related phenomena such as the phonological similarity effect pse should occur when the domainspecific.
Phonological representations of words are subject to partial loss due to decay and interference gathercole and baddeley, 1993. On the irrelevance of phonological similarity to the. Support for the phonological loop model has come from experiments with a wide range of tasks that stress vwm. Three experiments test the prediction that the effect of irrelevant sound and the effect of phonological similarity each survive the action of articulatory suppression but only when presentation of toberemembered lists is auditory, not visual. Using visual items, we trained 15 participants with id to use rehearsal strategies. Previous studies using working memory wm span tasks have shown that phonologically similar words were less recalled than dissimilar words in adults. In the case of visually presented items, pse requires verbal recoding before it appears. Traditionally, the phonological similarity effect refers to the finding that. The phonological similarity effect in shortterm memory. The phonological similarity effect in immediate recall. The purpose of this study was to extend the existing research available in support of the evidence for baddeley and hitch 1974 working memory model and the role of the phonological loop. Phonemic similarity effects and prelexical phonology 43 recognition because phonological factors influence pseudoword processing more so than word processing coltheart et a1. Phonological similarity within the remembered list impaired performance in both baseline and irrelevant speech conditions, whereas phonological similarity between the remembered and ignored irrelevant items did not influence performance.
Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. In our first two experiments, we show that the effect actually reverses following relatively brief periods of distraction, yielding better order retention for similar than for dissimilar lists, provided that different items are used on. In our first two experiments, we show that the effect actually reverses following relatively brief periods of distraction. What does it suggest if the phonological similarity effect occurs even when there is no auditory input, such as when you read the items silently to yourself. The classical phonological similarity effect pse was studied with words and nonwords in two immediate serial recall isr tasks. Reversing the phonological similarity effect james s. Evidence of a phonological similarity effect after. The roles of type of similarity, category cuing, and item recall. In comparison to phonologically dissimilar lists, when the stimulus lists rhyme there is a facilitative effect on the recall of item information and a detrimental effect on order memory. Pdf phonological similarity effects in verbal complex. Phonological similarity effects were used to assess the role of acoustic coding in verbal complex span, a processingplusstorage measure found to correlate significantly with aspects of complex cognition. Pdf phonological similarity in working memory researchgate.
The results indicate that the phonological loop works in this condition although the participant is required to produce a speech sound, that is, under the condition of articulatory suppression. In a series of four experiments, we explored what conditions are sufficient to produce a phonological similarity facilitation effect in working memory span tasks. The phonological similarity effectpoor retention of order for lists of similarsounding itemsis a benchmark finding in the shortterm memory literature. In 1974, baddeley and hitch introduced the multicomponent model of working memory. Kelley purdue university, west lafayette, indiana the phonological similarity effectpoor retention of order for lists of similarsounding itemsis a benchmark finding in the shortterm memory literature. Mean chronological age ca mean developmental age ma. Working memory is important for reasoning and the guidance of decisionmaking and behavior. The present study investigated the phonological similarity effect and rhyming effect using a fully crossed design to vary the availability of both mechanisms in children aged 6 to 8. How does the phonological similarity effect relate to memories in our everyday life.
471 959 1511 84 159 1057 167 1140 1530 580 703 495 205 1156 767 383 1025 1219 790 526 692 188 98 605 311 1335 675 1271 126 657 235 542 1043 1434 1393 620 543